Compare and choose from the top three hospitals for upper eyelid skin tightening in New York City in 2025!
As the first signs of aging often manifest around the eyes, upper eyelid skin tightening has become a sought - after cosmetic procedure in New York City. Many hospitals and clinics offer this service, but it can be overwhelming to choose the right one. In this article, we will compare the top three hospitals for upper eyelid skin tightening in NYC, helping you make an informed decision.
What is Upper Eyelid Skin Tightening?
Upper eyelid skin tightening, also known as upper blepharoplasty, is a minimally invasive procedure that subtly tightens and contours the tissues above the eye, promoting a more rejuvenated and youthful look. With age, tiny pockets of fat and excess skin can droop over the eyelid, creating “hooded” eyes or a more tired, aged expression. Collagen and elastin fibers begin to degrade as early as your mid - 30s, resulting in the weakening of the dermis, the layer of skin beneath the epidermis.
According to research (Oh SR, Chokthaweesak W, Annunziata CC, Priel A, Korn BS, Kikkawa DO. Analysis of eyelid fat pad changes with aging. Ophthalmic Plastic & Reconstructive Surgery. 2011; 27(5): 348 - 351), the lower and upper fat pads of the eyelid can become more prominent with time, exacerbated by dermal atrophy. In some cases, sagging skin can obstruct one’s field of vision, requiring a procedure to restore functionality.
Who is an Ideal Candidate for Upper Eyelid Skin Tightening?
Ideal candidates for upper eyelid skin tightening typically meet the following criteria:
- They have heavy, hooded eyelids that could benefit from contouring with minor amounts of skin and fat removal.
- Mostly, they are patients between 35 and 70 years old. However, younger patients with naturally hooded eyes can also be candidates.
- They are in good overall health without a blood - clotting disorder or another condition that slows down the healing process. For example, diabetics should have their blood sugar levels well - managed before considering the surgery.
- Those with conditions affecting eye health, such as Graves’ disease, high blood pressure, and glaucoma, need to be thoroughly evaluated by a surgeon.
- They have realistic expectations and are willing to follow aftercare instructions.
Top Three Hospitals for Upper Eyelid Skin Tightening in New York City
1. Dr. John E. Sherman's Practice
Surgeon Expertise
Dr. John E. Sherman is a board - certified plastic surgeon with over 40 years of experience. Throughout his career, he has performed thousands of surgeries, achieved various recognitions for his expertise, and is an active researcher in various medical journal publications. His artistic vision allows him to create a customized treatment plan that flatters the patient's overall appearance.
Procedure Details
The operation may be performed either under local anesthesia or supplemented with sedation administered by a board - certified anesthesiologist. Dr. Sherman will make a tiny horizontal incision within the crease of the eyelid, so any scarring is easily hidden. A small portion of skin and a small amount of the orbicularis muscle (the muscle surrounding the eye) are removed. The two fat pockets of the upper eyelid are then trimmed, restoring a cleaner, youthful look.
Recovery and Results
All eyelid lifts are outpatient procedures that take 1 hour or less, allowing patients to return home the same day. Dr. Sherman will prescribe an ointment to apply to the eyes to protect them from infection and aid in healing. In the first few days, swelling and discomfort are normal, but medications can provide relief. For the first 24 hours, patients are encouraged to keep their head elevated and use an ice pack on their eyelids. Typically, patients can go back to desk work around 4 to 7 days post - procedure. After about 1 week, the sutures are removed. Patients can usually go back to the gym after 1 month. The results of the eyelid lift will last about 10 to 15 years, depending on the patient's rate of aging and other lifestyle factors.
Cost
The cost of the upper eyelid surgery varies from patient to patient. A personal consultation with Dr. Sherman is the essential first step to getting an accurate estimate. Those interested in making affordable payments can explore financing options with PatientFi.
2. Dr. Philipp Franck's Practice
Surgeon Expertise
Dr. Philipp Franck is a board - certified plastic and reconstructive surgeon who completed his training at two prestigious Ivy League university hospitals. He is an expert in facial plastic surgery, including advanced blepharoplasty. Named one of New York’s rising star surgeons by the New York Times Magazine since 2023, he also serves as a clinical assistant professor at Cornell University Hospital in New York. His dedication to patient - centered care and consistently excellent surgical outcomes have earned him a place in Castle Connolly’s list of top doctors nationwide.
Procedure Details
Upper blepharoplasty is typically done under local anesthesia with sedation, but some patients may opt for general anesthesia depending on individual needs and comfort levels. Dr. Franck carefully marks the areas around the eyelids to determine how much skin or fat should be removed. Incisions are made within the natural creases of the upper eyelid to hide scars. Excess skin, fat, and sometimes muscle are removed or repositioned to create a more youthful contour. Fine sutures are used to minimize scarring, and stitches are typically removed within a few days.
Recovery and Results
Patients routinely return home the same day and experience minimal discomfort. In the first week, mild swelling, bruising, or irritation may be noticed. Continuing cold compresses and head elevation help with swelling. Sutures are usually removed within 5 - 7 days. Many people resume light activities within a week or two, though strenuous exercise should be avoided for a few weeks. As swelling diminishes, the refreshed, youthful appearance of the eyes becomes apparent. Full healing can take a few months, but changes are noticeable much sooner.
Cost
The cost of the procedure can be discussed during the consultation. Dr. Franck will provide a detailed explanation of the factors that contribute to the cost, such as the complexity of the case and the specific techniques used.
3. Mount Sinai - New York
Surgeon Expertise
Mount Sinai has a team of expert plastic surgeons who are highly skilled in performing cosmetic eyelid surgery with precision. They work in collaboration with vision specialists to ensure that the procedure not only enhances the appearance of the eyes but also addresses any potential visual impairment.
Procedure Details
During eyelid surgery, the plastic surgeon can camouflage the incision by making it in the crease of the upper eyelid. The surgeon will lift the loose, sagging upper eyelids, correct under - eye bags, restore better peripheral vision affected by loose eyelid skin, and remove fatty deposits from the upper eyelids. The team at Mount Sinai uses the latest techniques and technologies to achieve the best results.
Recovery and Results
Patients can expect to see an improvement in the appearance of their eyes, with a more youthful and refreshed look. Recovery time and post - operative care instructions will be provided by the surgical team. The hospital will also follow up with patients to ensure a smooth recovery and optimal results.
Cost
The cost of the upper eyelid surgery at Mount Sinai varies. If the procedure is done to correct visual impairment, with the recommendation of an eye doctor, patients may be able to get approval for insurance coverage. A consultation with the surgeons at Mount Sinai will help determine the exact cost and insurance eligibility.
Comparison of the Three Hospitals
| Criteria | Dr. John E. Sherman's Practice | Dr. Philipp Franck's Practice | Mount Sinai - New York |
|---|---|---|---|
| Surgeon Experience | Over 40 years of experience, active researcher | Trained at Ivy League hospitals, rising star surgeon, clinical assistant professor | Team of expert plastic surgeons, collaborate with vision specialists |
| Procedure Approach | Horizontal incision in upper eyelid crease, remove skin, muscle, and fat pockets | Marking eyelids, incisions in natural creases, remove/reposition skin, fat, and muscle | Camouflage incisions in upper eyelid crease, lift eyelids, correct bags, remove fatty deposits |
| Recovery Time | Desk work: 4 - 7 days; gym: 1 month | Light activities: 1 - 2 weeks; strenuous exercise: a few weeks; full healing: a few months | Not specified, will follow up with patients |
| Cost | Varies, financing options available | Discussed during consultation | Varies, possible insurance coverage for visual impairment cases |
Preparing for Upper Eyelid Skin Tightening
Regardless of which hospital you choose, there are some general preparation steps you should take:
- Medical Clearance: Your surgeon may request medical clearance to ensure your safety. This may include blood tests to evaluate other aspects of your health and address any major issues.
- Stop Smoking: If you smoke or consume nicotine regularly, you should stop at least 1 month before your procedure appointment. Nicotine and other chemicals in cigarettes can slow down the healing process by constricting blood vessels.
- Medication Adjustment: Your surgeon will review your current supplements and medications and require you to stop taking anything with blood - thinning properties. This reduces the likelihood of excessive bruising during recovery and complications during the procedure.
- Prescriptions and Supplies: Before your surgery, pick up any necessary prescriptions and stock up on over - the - counter medications approved by your surgeon.
- Arrangements: Make an arrangement with a family member or friend to pick you up and take you home after this outpatient procedure.
FAQs
Can an upper eyelid lift correct crow’s feet?
Since crow’s feet are adjacent to the upper eyelid, an upper blepharoplasty will not correct these minor wrinkles. Eyelid lifts tighten lax skin directly over the eye.
What is the best age for an upper eyelid lift?
Usually, patients begin to notice unwanted sagging in the upper eyelid after 40, but younger patients who have naturally hooded eyes can undergo the procedure as well.
Will I have noticeable scars after an upper eyelid lift?
This procedure requires an incision at the top crease of the upper eyelid, so any resulting scars will blend in with the natural crease’s shadow and heal significantly over time.
Conclusion
Choosing the right hospital for upper eyelid skin tightening in New York City is a crucial decision that depends on various factors such as surgeon expertise, procedure approach, recovery time, and cost. Dr. John E. Sherman's practice offers long - standing experience and a personalized approach. Dr. Philipp Franck's practice provides a high - level of training and a patient - centered care model. Mount Sinai - New York offers a collaborative approach with vision specialists and potential insurance coverage for certain cases.
Before making a decision, it is highly recommended to schedule consultations with the surgeons at these hospitals. During the consultations, you can ask questions, discuss your concerns and goals, and get a better understanding of what to expect from the procedure. We encourage you to share this article with others who may be interested in upper eyelid skin tightening and explore our other articles on cosmetic procedures for more information.
