Introduction
Prosthetic breast implant removal surgery has become a relevant topic for many women in New York City. There are multiple reasons why a woman might choose to have her breast implants removed, such as complications with the implants, unsatisfactory results, or health - related concerns. In this article, we will delve into the real - person cases and feedback regarding the ranking of doctors for prosthetic breast implant removal surgery in New York City in 2025.
Reasons for Breast Implant Removal
Before looking at the doctors, it's essential to understand the common reasons for breast implant removal:
- Aesthetic Issues: The implants may become palpable, visible, or develop ripples, folds, or wrinkles. Implant rupture, leakage, or deflation can also occur. Additionally, problems like capsular contracture, where the soft - tissue envelope around the implants hardens, causing distortion and an abnormal appearance of the breasts, can be a significant concern. Breast asymmetry, unsightly scars, and malposition of the implants, such as a “double bubble” or “symmastia” appearance, are also reasons women seek removal. For instance, some patients might find that the size or position of the implants no longer suits their body or aesthetic preferences.
- Medical Issues: Severe capsular contracture can lead to pain and discomfort, not just cosmetic problems. There are also rare but serious medical conditions like breast implant - associated anaplastic large cell lymphoma (BIA - ALCL) and breast implant illness (BII). BII refers to a wide range of symptoms including fatigue, fever, gastrointestinal complaints, migraines, breathing difficulties, and more. The exact cause of BII is uncertain, but it is believed to be related to pre - existing autoimmune problems.
Doctors and Their Real - Person Feedback in New York City
Dr. Trevor M. Born
Dr. Trevor M. Born is a certified plastic surgeon with 28 years of experience and 2 board certifications. He is located at 910 Fifth Ave., Ste. B, New York, New York, and accepts virtual consultations. According to real - person stories, one patient believed that Dr. Born is the best plastic surgeon without exception. The patient initially met Dr. Born as he had to correct the breast augmentation that she had done previously. This feedback indicates that Dr. Born has significant skill in dealing with post - augmentation complications, which is also crucial in breast implant removal cases, as many removal surgeries may involve fixing issues from previous procedures.
Dr. Kevin Tehrani
Dr. Kevin Tehrani, a board - certified plastic surgeon with 21 years of experience and 1 board certification, is based at 33 W. 56th St., New York. He also accepts virtual consultations. A patient who got breast augmentation in March 2016 ended up with a capsular contracture on one breast. Dissatisfied with the look, the patient went to Dr. Tehrani for a revision. This shows that Dr. Tehrani has the expertise to handle cases where complications have arisen after breast augmentation, which is closely related to breast implant removal surgeries when patients face similar problems.
Dr. Samuel Rhee
Dr. Samuel Rhee, a board - certified plastic surgeon with 19 years of experience and 1 board certification, is located at 12 N. State Rte. 17, Ste. 304, Paramus, New Jersey (close to New York City). He accepts virtual consultations. A patient had a very positive experience with Dr. Rhee for breast implants removal in July 2023. The patient appreciated aspects of Dr. Rhee's approach, though the specific details were not elaborated. However, positive feedback in general gives an indication of the doctor's competence and patient - friendly nature.
Dr. Leland Deane
Dr. Leland Deane, a board - certified plastic surgeon with 38 years of experience and 1 board certification, can be found at 1111 Park Ave., Ste. 1G, New York. He accepts virtual consultations. A patient had an amazing experience with Dr. Deane for an explant. The doctor was described as kind, knowledgeable, and professional, and the patient's recovery was quick with good results. This feedback highlights the doctor's skills in performing the surgery and also his patient - care abilities.
Dr. Finny George
Dr. Finny George, a board - certified plastic surgeon with 12 years of experience and 1 board certification, is based at 1040 Park Ave., Ste. 1BC, New York. He accepts virtual consultations. A patient had an amazing experience from the start with Dr. George. The patient was so impressed that he was the first and only doctor the patient consulted with. This kind of high - level trust from a patient reflects well on Dr. George's reputation and abilities in the field of breast implant removal.
Dr. Douglas Taranow
Dr. Douglas Taranow, a board - certified plastic surgeon with 29 years of experience and 1 board certification, is located at 169 E. 69th St., New York. He offers gender - affirming care. A patient has a long history with Dr. Taranow, dating back to 2004 when he performed the patient's breast augmentation surgery, and the patient went back to him for some follow - up procedures later. This long - term patient - doctor relationship shows the patient's trust in Dr. Taranow over the years, which could also be relevant in breast implant removal surgeries.
Dr. Irena Karanetz
Dr. Irena Karanetz, a board - certified plastic surgeon with 6 years of experience and 1 board certification, is at 1040 Park Ave, New York. She accepts virtual consultations and offers gender - affirming care. A patient highly recommended Dr. Karanetz, stating that her warm and professional demeanor and expertise made the patient's experience worthwhile. This feedback emphasizes the doctor's personal qualities and technical skills in the surgical process.
Dr. Michael Constantin Gartner
Dr. Michael Constantin Gartner, a board - certified plastic surgeon with 22 years of experience and 2 board certifications, is located at 122 East 64th St., New York. He accepts virtual consultations. A patient found Dr. Gartner after having a bad experience with another “plastic surgeon.” The patient almost had a bad procedure with the other doctor, but Dr. Gartner seemed to offer a better option, which implies that Dr. Gartner has the ability to handle complex cases and provide better - informed decisions for patients.
Dr. Richard G. Reish
Dr. Richard G. Reish, a board - certified plastic surgeon with 16 years of experience and 1 board certification, is based at 1040 Park Ave., Ste. 1BC, New York. He accepts virtual consultations and offers gender - affirming care. A patient described Dr. Reish as the surgeon anyone would want to see. He was said to be kind, professional, and have hyper - excellent surgical precision, and he was very honest with the patient. This feedback underlines the doctor's professional ethics and surgical skills.
Dr. Adam Schaffner
Dr. Adam Schaffner, a board - certified plastic surgeon with 21 years of experience and 3 board certifications, is located at 590 5th Ave., Ste. 1101, New York. He accepts virtual consultations and offers gender - affirming care. A patient first went to Dr. Schaffner approximately 8 years ago for an implant replacement and breast augmentation, and the doctor's work was described as like no other, with the most natural - looking results. This long - standing positive experience suggests that Dr. Schaffner has consistent skills in breast - related surgeries, which would also be beneficial in breast implant removal.
Dr. Nina Naidu
Dr. Nina Naidu has received numerous positive testimonials regarding breast implant removal. Patients have described her as highly professional, sensitive, and having good feedback. Her practice staff is also highly regarded. One patient picked Dr. Naidu for the delicate procedure of breast implants removal safely and would not hesitate to recommend her to others. Another patient knew from the moment of the consultation that Dr. Naidu was the right surgeon, as she had a professional and comforting manner, related well to the patient's issues, and was realistic about expectations. These testimonials show that Dr. Naidu is not only skilled in surgery but also excels in patient communication and care.
Dr. Olivia Hutchinson
Dr. Olivia Hutchinson is recognized as a top breast implant removal surgeon in NYC, with over 20 years of experience evaluating patients with breast implant - related concerns. She can deal with both aesthetic and medical issues related to breast implants. A patient's experience with Dr. Hutchinson and her staff was exceptional. The atmosphere was calming, everything was clean, and the staff was professional and nice. Dr. Hutchinson made the patient feel comfortable, and the results were amazing. This feedback indicates that Dr. Hutchinson has the expertise to handle complex cases and also provides a positive patient experience.
Dr. Barry Weintraub
Dr. Barry Weintraub performs breast implant removal and replacement surgeries. He takes a patient - centered approach, preferring the patient to be in a comfortable state of twilight sleep during the surgery. He insists on the highest sterile conditions in the operating room and performs the surgery himself with precision. His aesthetic is sophisticated, aiming for natural - looking results. Patients can expect significant and long - lasting aesthetic improvements to their breasts after the procedure. Real - person experiences are not as explicitly detailed in the references as some other doctors, but his approach and the description of his surgery process suggest that he is a reliable choice for breast implant - related surgeries.
Comparing Doctors Based on Real - Person Feedback
| Doctor | Years of Experience | Board Certifications | Key Feedback Highlights |
|---|---|---|---|
| Dr. Trevor M. Born | 28 | 2 | Considered the best by a patient for correcting prior breast augmentation |
| Dr. Kevin Tehrani | 21 | 1 | Skilled in handling capsular contracture cases after augmentation |
| Dr. Samuel Rhee | 19 | 1 | Positive patient experience for breast implant removal |
| Dr. Leland Deane | 38 | 1 | Kind, knowledgeable, and led to quick recovery with good results |
| Dr. Finny George | 12 | 1 | First and only doctor a patient consulted due to amazing start |
| Dr. Douglas Taranow | 29 | 1 | Long - term patient - doctor relationship for breast - related surgeries |
| Dr. Irena Karanetz | 6 | 1 | Warm, professional, and made patient's experience worthwhile |
| Dr. Michael Constantin Gartner | 22 | 2 | Offered better option after a patient's bad experience with another doctor |
| Dr. Richard G. Reish | 16 | 1 | Kind, professional, with excellent surgical precision and honesty |
| Dr. Adam Schaffner | 21 | 3 | Produced natural - looking results in previous breast surgeries |
| Dr. Nina Naidu | Not specified | Not specified | Highly professional, sensitive, and great patient communication |
| Dr. Olivia Hutchinson | Over 20 | Not specified | Top - rated, exceptional patient experience and results |
| Dr. Barry Weintraub | Not specified | Not specified | Patient - centered approach, precise surgery for aesthetic improvement |
How to Choose the Right Doctor
When choosing a doctor for prosthetic breast implant removal surgery in New York City, consider the following factors based on the real - person feedback:
- Experience: Look for doctors with significant years of experience, especially in dealing with breast - related surgeries and any complications that may be relevant to your case. Doctors like Dr. Leland Deane with 38 years of experience have had more opportunities to handle a wide range of situations.
- Board Certifications: Board - certified doctors, such as many of those mentioned above, have met certain standards in their field. Multiple board certifications can be a sign of additional expertise.
- Patient Feedback: Real - person stories can give you an insight into the doctor's surgical skills, patient - care abilities, and overall patient experience. Positive feedback regarding communication, bedside manner, and surgical results is crucial.
- Reputation: A doctor's reputation in the medical community and among patients matters. You can ask for recommendations from other patients, medical professionals, or check online reviews.
- Compatibility: It's important to feel comfortable with your doctor. You should be able to communicate your concerns and expectations clearly, and the doctor should listen and provide honest and realistic advice. For example, if you need a doctor who can speak your language, like Dr. Rady Rahban who is fluent in Spanish for Spanish - speaking patients, that can be a deciding factor.
Conclusion
In New York City in 2025, there are several highly - qualified doctors for prosthetic breast implant removal surgery. Real - person feedback provides valuable insights into the skills, patient - care abilities, and reputations of these doctors. From those with long - standing experience like Dr. Leland Deane to doctors who have received high praise for their surgical precision and patient communication like Dr. Richard G. Reish, patients have a range of options to choose from. Each doctor brings their own strengths to the table, whether it's handling post - augmentation complications, providing a comfortable patient experience, or achieving excellent aesthetic results.
If you are considering prosthetic breast implant removal surgery, take the time to research these doctors based on the factors mentioned above. Consult with multiple doctors, if possible, to find the one who is the best fit for your specific needs. Remember to ask questions, understand the surgical process, and make an informed decision. Share this article with others who may be interested in learning about breast implant removal surgery in New York City and continue to explore more resources on the topic to ensure you are well - informed.
