Introduction
Membranous nasal septum resection is a crucial surgical procedure for individuals suffering from a deviated septum, which can lead to breathing difficulties, sinus issues, and other health problems. In New York City, a bustling metropolis with a wide array of medical facilities, both public and private hospitals are vying for a spot in the top - 10 rankings for this specific surgical procedure. This article delves into the details of these hospitals, the surgeons performing the operations, the surgical techniques, and the factors that contribute to their rankings.
Understanding Membranous Nasal Septum Resection
What is Membranous Nasal Septum Resection?
Membranous nasal septum resection, also known as septoplasty, is a surgical procedure aimed at correcting a deviated nasal septum. The nasal septum is the partition that divides the two nasal cavities. When it deviates from the center line and into one of the nasal cavities, it can cause obstruction, making it difficult to breathe. Deviations can be the result of an injury or can occur during childbirth. As per NYU Langone Health, this condition can also lead to other issues such as sinus infections, snoring, and sleep apnea.
Indications for the Procedure
This surgery is typically indicated for individuals with recurrent rhinitis, a deviated septum, or other chronic sinusitis. It can also be performed to alleviate recurrent epistaxis (nosebleeds) due to septal impaction or septal spur. Additionally, it can be done for cosmetic purposes to straighten a crooked or deviated nose. However, the surgery should not be performed on patients presenting with acute sinus or nasal infection, and individuals with untreated diabetes, bleeding diathesis, or severe hypertension are not candidates for this procedure.
Surgeons Performing Membranous Nasal Septum Resection in New York
According to Healthgrades, there are 970 doctors who perform nasal septum surgery in New York. Some of the highly - rated surgeons are:
| Surgeon's Name | Rating | Location |
|---|---|---|
| Dr. Ashutosh Kacker, MD | 4.90 out of 5 stars | 1305 York Avenue 5th floor, New York, NY 10021 |
| Dr. Calvin Wei, MD | 4.70 out of 5 stars | 425 W 59th st fl 10, New York, NY 10019 |
| Dr. Mukesh Prasad, MD | 4.90 out of 5 stars | 1305 York Avenue 5th floor, New York, NY 10021 |
| Dr. Abtin Tabaee, MD | 4.90 out of 5 stars | 156 William Street 12th floor, New York, NY 10038 |
| Dr. William Lawson, MD | 3.70 out of 5 stars | 5 E 98th st fl 8, New York, NY 10029 |
These surgeons play a vital role in the success of membranous nasal septum resection. Their experience, expertise, and patient - centered approach contribute to the overall quality of care provided at the hospitals where they practice.
Top - Ranked Hospitals for Membranous Nasal Septum Resection in New York City
Public Hospitals
NYC Health + Hospitals is the largest municipal health care system in the nation. Their hospitals have been recognized by U.S. News & World Report in the 2024 - 2025 ‘Best Hospitals’ list for treating various conditions. Although not specifically ranked for membranous nasal septum resection, their general recognition for high - quality care in multiple specialties gives an indication of their potential to perform well in this procedure. Some of the notable public hospitals within the system are:
- NYC Health + Hospitals/Bellevue: Recognized for treating heart failure and heart attack. Their comprehensive medical services and large pool of experienced medical staff may also contribute to successful nasal septum resections.
- NYC Health + Hospitals/Elmhurst: With recognition for treating heart failure, heart attack, hip fracture, and kidney failure, this hospital's multi - specialty capabilities can support the surgical and post - operative care required for septoplasty.
Private Hospitals
Private hospitals in New York City are also known for their high - end medical facilities and specialized care. Some of the top private hospitals in the ear, nose, and throat category according to U.S. News Best Hospitals are relevant for membranous nasal septum resection:
- Memorial Sloan Kettering Cancer Center: Nationally ranked in 7 adult specialties and 1 pediatric specialty. Although primarily known for cancer treatment, their expertise in head and neck surgeries may also extend to nasal septum resections.
- New York - Presbyterian Hospital - Columbia and Cornell: Ranked in 14 adult specialties and 10 pediatric specialties. Their extensive research and clinical experience in various medical fields can provide patients with comprehensive pre - and post - operative care.
Comparison of Public and Private Hospitals in the Top 10 Ranking
When it comes to the top 10 ranking for membranous nasal septum resection, both public and private hospitals have their own strengths.
Cost
Public hospitals, such as those within the NYC Health + Hospitals system, generally offer more affordable options for patients, especially for those with limited financial resources or government - sponsored insurance. Private hospitals, on the other hand, may have higher costs due to their advanced facilities and specialized services. However, they may also offer more personalized care and shorter waiting times.
Resources and Expertise
Private hospitals often have access to the latest medical technologies and research. They can attract top - notch surgeons and specialists due to better financial incentives. Public hospitals, while also having skilled medical staff, may have more challenges in terms of funding for the latest equipment. However, they often have a large patient base, which means their doctors gain a lot of experience treating a wide variety of cases.
Patient Experience
Private hospitals usually focus on providing a more luxurious and comfortable patient experience, with private rooms, personalized nursing care, and shorter wait times. Public hospitals may have more crowded waiting areas and longer wait times, but they offer a sense of community and are often more accessible to underserved populations.
Surgical Techniques in Membranous Nasal Septum Resection
Septoplasty
Septoplasty is a procedure to center the septum, creating two nasal passages that are the same size. A surgeon uses small surgical instruments to make an incision in the tissue lining the septum. He or she then straightens or repositions the deviated section of the septum to maximize airflow through the nasal passages. If the septum is damaged in addition to being out of place, doctors may remove small pieces of cartilage or bone. According to Cangello Plastic Surgery, most septoplasty procedures are comprised of five steps which include the initial incision to expose the deviated septum, identifying and releasing the internal structures that are the cause of angulations, realigning the septum, reimplanting crushed cartilage (when appropriate), and closure of the incision.
Septorhinoplasty
If an injury such as a fracture is the cause of a nasal obstruction, or if surgery to reposition the septum changes the appearance of the nose, surgeons may perform septorhinoplasty. During this procedure, the surgeons eliminate the nasal obstruction and use cosmetic techniques that ensure that the nose looks natural. Surgeons perform septorhinoplasty through the nostrils, correct the position of the septum, and address any other structural problems.
Submucosal Resection
In submucosal resection, a surgeon removes small sections of the septum, the turbinates, or both to open the nasal passages. A surgeon accesses the septum or turbinates through the nostrils and makes a small incision in the layer of soft tissue lining the nasal passage. This incision allows surgeons to remove portions of the underlying bone structure without disturbing the outer layer of tissue, which plays an important role in keeping the nasal passages hydrated.
Factors Affecting Hospital Rankings
Patient Outcomes
One of the most important factors in hospital rankings is patient outcomes. This includes the success rate of the surgery, the rate of complications, and the recovery time of patients. Hospitals that consistently achieve high success rates and low complication rates are more likely to be ranked higher.
Medical Staff Expertise
The experience and expertise of the medical staff, including surgeons, nurses, and anesthesiologists, play a crucial role in hospital rankings. Hospitals with highly - trained and experienced medical staff are better equipped to handle complex cases and provide high - quality care.
Facilities and Technology
Modern facilities and advanced medical technology can improve the accuracy and safety of surgeries. Hospitals that invest in the latest equipment and technologies are more likely to offer better treatment options and achieve better patient outcomes.
Conclusion
In conclusion, in the top 10 ranking of membranous nasal septum resection in New York City, both public and private hospitals have their own unique advantages and are vying for the top spots. Public hospitals offer affordability and a large patient - base for experience, while private hospitals provide advanced facilities and personalized care. The surgical techniques used in membranous nasal septum resection are diverse and depend on the patient's condition. Factors such as patient outcomes, medical staff expertise, and facilities and technology all contribute to the hospital rankings.
If you or someone you know is considering membranous nasal septum resection, it is important to do thorough research on the hospitals and surgeons, consider the pros and cons of public and private facilities, and make an informed decision based on your specific needs and circumstances. Don't hesitate to consult with medical professionals to get more detailed information and guidance on this important surgical procedure.
