Ranking based on real feedback from netizens for breast implant removal plastic surgery in New York City in 2025!

Introduction

Breast implant removal, also known as explantation, has become an increasingly sought - after procedure in New York City. As breast augmentation has been a popular cosmetic surgery, some individuals now wish to reverse the process for various reasons, whether medical or aesthetic. In this article, we will delve into the rankings of breast implant removal plastic surgeries in New York City, basing our findings on real feedback from netizens. We will also discuss the procedure, its implications, and review the surgeons and facilities based on patient testimonials.

Understanding Breast Implant Removal

What is Breast Implant Removal?

Breast implant removal is a surgical procedure that reverses a prior breast augmentation without replacing the implants. As described on Steven Wallach MD's website, the surgeon usually makes an incision using the previous breast implant surgical approach to access the pocket created for the implants and removes them before sealing the incision site with sutures. This may involve incisions along the breast fold, the periareola region, or through a transaxillary incision in the armpit. In case of ruptured silicone implants, the surgeon will also remove the implant filler material.

Reasons for Breast Implant Removal

There are both medical and non - medical reasons for breast implant removal:

• Medical Reasons:
  • Implant Rupture: A rupture can occur in both saline and silicone implants. For saline implants, the breast will deflate as the sterile saline solution leaks out and is absorbed by the body. In the case of silicone implants, it may look different than normal, and an MRI may be required to determine if it has ruptured.
  • Capsular Contracture: This is the hardening of scar tissue that forms around an implant after it is placed in the body. Normally, this tissue is soft and unnoticeable, but it can become hard and painful, distorting the appearance of the breasts. The rate of capsular contracture is about 3 - 4%, and it gradually increases over the years. Early signs include pain, hardness, tightness, and a change in the shape of the breast.
  • Breast Implant - Associated Anaplastic Large Cell Lymphoma (BIA - ALCL): A rare cancer specifically related to breast implants. Some women with textured implants made by Allergan have chosen to have their implants removed due to a recall in 2019. BIA - ALCL often presents as a mass or fluid accumulation, mostly treatable with surgical removal of the tumor, capsule, and breast implant.
  • Breast Implant Illness (BII): Refers to a wide variety of symptoms such as fatigue, fever, gastrointestinal complaints, migraines, breathing difficulties, depression or anxiety, rashes, pain and discomfort, and brain fog. The cause of BII is uncertain but is believed to be associated with pre - existing autoimmune problems.
• Non - Medical Reasons:
  • Change in Aesthetic Preferences: Over time, an individual's desired appearance may change, and they may prefer to return to a more natural look.
  • Unsatisfactory Results: Some patients may be unhappy with the initial outcome of their breast augmentation, such as the size, shape, or position of the implants.

Patient Satisfaction and Reviews

RealPatientRatings.com

According to RealPatientRatings.com, breast implant removal has a 96.2% patient satisfaction rate based on 2272 ratings. The breakdown of star ratings is as follows:

RealSelf.com

RealSelf features 4,408 breast implant removal reviews from real people. Overall, 97% of the reviewers said the procedure was “worth it.” Some individual reviews provide insights into different experiences:

• Positive Experiences:
  • One patient highly recommended Dr. Rankin and his team, stating that they went above and beyond. The patient felt heard, understood, and truly cared for, and the explant surgery was made easy.
  • Another patient who had breast implants for over 19 years and was 4 weeks post - explant surgery said it was the best decision. They were satisfied with the outcome and the overall experience.
  • A patient with serious Breast Implant Illness (BII) symptoms was happy with the explant procedure performed by Dr. Howell. The patient noted that the doctor and staff were easy to deal with, and the BII symptoms were improving every day.
• Negative Experiences:
  • One patient had an explant and breast lift with Dr. Royal Khan Kishi Yev. The patient reported a nightmare experience, starting with rude behavior from the doctor and poor after - care. The patient also lost nipple sensation and had irregular muscle contractions.
  • Another patient had dog - ear scarring on both sides of the breast after the procedure. The patient mentioned that the correction of the scarring would cost over $1k, and the surgeon was a bit defensive about the results during the healing process.

Top Plastic Surgeons for Breast Implant Removal in NYC

Dr. Steven Wallach

Dr. Steven Wallach, as described on his website, has extensive experience in breast implant removal. He walks patients through every step of the process, from consultation to recovery. During the consultation, he assesses the patient's situation, whether it's a medical complication like capsular contracture or a cosmetic concern. He explains the available options and techniques, aiming to provide the best results with the least amount of scarring. Dr. Wallach also addresses patients' concerns about risks, costs, and recovery time. He advises patients on preparation, such as familiarizing them with relevant medical terms and asking them to avoid certain medications that may cause bleeding. For the procedure, he uses either intravenous (IV) sedation or general anesthesia for the patient's comfort and safety. After the surgery, he provides clear instructions for recovery, including activity restrictions and follow - up appointments.

Dr. Olivia Hutchinson

Recognized as the top breast implant removal surgeon in NYC on her website, Dr. Olivia Hutchinson has over 20 years of experience evaluating patients with breast implant - related concerns. She can address both functional and cosmetic issues related to breast implants. For aesthetic issues such as implant palpability, rupture, or malposition, as well as medical issues like severe capsular contracture and BII, she offers appropriate surgical options. She also educates patients about rare conditions like BIA - ALCL and helps them make informed decisions. Patients who have undergone procedures with Dr. Hutchinson have reported exceptional experiences, with the doctor making them feel comfortable and achieving amazing results.

Dr. Daniel Maman

Dr. Daniel Maman, a Harvard fellowship - trained and board - certified plastic surgeon, is specialized in cosmetic and reconstructive surgery of the breast, body, and face. As mentioned on his website, in the context of breast implant removal, which is often part of breast implant revision procedures, he offers a comprehensive approach. His 90 - minute consultation includes a thorough review of the patient's medical history, an in - depth physical assessment, and the development of a detailed operative plan. He provides clear information about costs, accommodations, and follow - up visits. During the surgery, he emphasizes convenience, comfort, and a smooth recovery for the patient, with options like luxury recovery rooms at NYC hotels. His after - care is also meticulous, ensuring optimal results for the patients.

The Process of Breast Implant Removal

Consultation

The consultation is a crucial step in the breast implant removal process. Different surgeons approach it in their own ways, but generally, they start by discussing the patient's reasons for wanting the implants removed. If it's due to a medical complication, the surgeon may perform an examination to confirm the diagnosis. For example, in the case of capsular contracture, the surgeon may feel the breast tissue to assess its firmness. If the concern is cosmetic, the surgeon will explore the patient's aesthetic goals, such as whether they are interested in breast implant replacement or other breast enhancement options like a breast lift. Surgeons also explain the procedure, including the type of incision that will be used, the expected recovery time, and the potential risks and complications. They answer all the patient's questions to ensure that the patient is well - informed and can make a confident decision.

Preparation

Patients need to make some preparations before the surgery. They should be familiar with important medical terms related to breast implants, such as ptosis (sagging of the breasts), deflation (in the case of saline implants), capsulectomy (removal of the breast implant and the surrounding scar tissue), and explantation (removal of the implant). Patients are also usually advised to stop smoking and taking blood - thinning medications before the procedure to reduce the risk of bleeding. Additionally, they should arrange for a caregiver to drive them home from the surgery center and stay with them for about a day after the operation.

Procedure

The breast implant removal procedure is typically performed under intravenous (IV) sedation or general anesthesia for the patient's comfort and safety. Once the anesthesia takes effect, the surgeon makes an incision to access the breast pocket and the implant. The implant is then carefully removed. In some cases, the surgeon may also remove the scar capsule surrounding the implant, especially if there is a problem like capsular contracture. If the implant has ruptured and there is leakage of silicone gel, the surgeon takes extra care to remove all the gel. After the implant is removed, if the patient has elected to have new implants inserted, the surgeon will proceed with the replacement according to the agreed - upon surgical plan. Finally, the incisions are closed, and the incision sites are bandaged.

Recovery

Immediately after the procedure, patients will experience swelling and bruising around the breasts and may have mild pain. The level of pain can vary depending on whether the implants were removed or replaced. Patients need to have a caregiver with them for the first day. Most patients can return to light activity within three to five days. However, they are advised to avoid aerobic activity for three to four weeks and heavy lifting for about six to eight weeks. Surgeons also schedule follow - up appointments to monitor the healing process and address any concerns the patient may have.

Risks and Complications

As with any surgical procedure, breast implant removal has its risks and complications:

• Scarring: There is a risk of unfavorable scarring at the incision site. The appearance of the scar can vary depending on factors such as the patient's skin type, the location of the incision, and how well the wound heals.
• Asymmetry: The breasts may not be perfectly symmetrical after the implant removal. This can be due to differences in the amount of scar tissue, swelling, or the original anatomy of the breasts.
• Infection: There is a risk of infection at the incision site or in the breast tissue. Signs of infection include redness, swelling, pain, and fever. If an infection occurs, it may require treatment with antibiotics.
• Bleeding: Some bleeding may occur during or after the surgery. In most cases, it can be controlled during the procedure, but in rare cases, additional treatment may be needed.
• Nipple Loss: Although rare, there is a small risk of nipple loss during the surgery. This can be due to damage to the blood supply or nerves to the nipple.
• Skin Loss: Skin loss can occur, usually at the incision site. It may be due to poor blood circulation or infection.
• Fat Necrosis: This is the death of fat cells in the breast. It can cause lumps or changes in the shape of the breast and may require further evaluation or treatment.
• Fluid Collections: Fluid may collect in the breast tissue after the surgery, which can cause swelling and discomfort. In some cases, the fluid may need to be drained.
• Dysesthesias: Patients may experience changes in sensation in the breasts, such as numbness, tingling, or hypersensitivity. These sensations may be temporary or permanent.
• Need for Revision Surgery: In some cases, patients may require revision surgery to correct complications or achieve the desired aesthetic results.

Cost of Breast Implant Removal

The cost of breast implant removal can vary depending on several factors. According to Steven Wallach MD's website, the fee may start at $5000, but it will increase if breast implant replacement is desired or if a more complex procedure such as a lift is required. Other factors that can affect the cost include the surgeon's experience and reputation, the location of the surgical facility, and the type of anesthesia used. It's important for patients to have a clear understanding of all the costs involved during the consultation with the surgeon.

Conclusion

Breast implant removal in New York City is a procedure that offers individuals the opportunity to address various concerns related to their breast implants, whether medical or aesthetic. Based on real feedback from netizens, there are several highly - regarded plastic surgeons in the city who have the experience and skill to perform this procedure safely and effectively. However, like any surgical procedure, it comes with risks and requires careful consideration.

If you are considering breast implant removal, we encourage you to thoroughly research your options, read patient reviews, and schedule consultations with multiple surgeons. By making an informed decision, you can increase your chances of a successful outcome and a satisfying experience. Share this article with others who may be interested in learning more about breast implant removal in New York City, and feel free to explore our other resources on plastic surgery procedures.