Reviews of Plastic Hospitals for Eyelid Bag Liposuction in New York City in 2025

New York City, a bustling metropolis known for its diverse culture and cutting - edge beauty trends, offers a plethora of plastic hospitals specializing in eyelid bag liposuction. In 2025, many individuals are turning to these clinics to enhance their appearance and regain their confidence. This article compiles reviews of several well - known plastic hospitals in the city to help you make an informed decision.

1. Dr. Amiya Prasad Clinic

Overview

Dr. Amiya Prasad has built a solid reputation in the field of eyelid surgery. He is an occuloplastic surgeon with a specialty in eye surgeries, revisions of bad surgeries, and reconstructive surgeries.

Patient Reviews

• Many patients have praised Dr. Prasad for his exceptional skills. One patient said, “Dr. Prasad removed my under - eye bags 2 years ago. Super happy with the results. Last week my sister had the same procedure done by him. Great skills, pleasant personality!”
• Another patient who had a trans - conjuctival blepharoplasty in April stated, “The procedure was painless. My results have been astonishing. After 6 days my eyes looked amazing. Dr. Prasad’s technique with PRP injections left me with no bruising at all.”
• Patients also appreciate the attentive staff. “The staff was amazing and attentive. Dr. Prasad made me feel comfortable when choosing a cosmetic surgeon to work on my eyes. He left the floor open for me to address any concerns and treated me as though I mattered, not just another face coming in for a procedure,” a satisfied patient mentioned.

Summary

Overall, Dr. Prasad’s clinic seems to offer high - quality services with natural - looking results. The doctor's patience, skill, and the staff's attentiveness are highly regarded by patients.

2. Manhattan Surgical Care (Dr. Basil Pakeman)

Overview

Manhattan Surgical Care, under the leadership of Dr. Basil Pakeman, provides various cosmetic surgery procedures, including those related to the eyes and face.

Patient Reviews

• Some patients have had excellent experiences. One patient who had a BBL, neck, chin, and jowl lipo said, “My life is literally changed. Dr. Pakeman did a phenomenal job and really listened to my vision. The whole process was simple and straightforward, and the whole staff was extremely kind and helpful.”
• However, there are also negative reviews. A patient who went to have a blefero and remove under - eye bags said, “He messed up completely. My face after 1 year didn’t recover. Now I have the bags where they weren’t before, and the scars from the blefero are still there.”

Summary

Dr. Pakeman's work seems to be a mixed bag. While some patients are extremely satisfied with their results and the overall experience, others have faced significant complications and are unhappy with the outcome.

3. Dr. Barry Weintraub

Overview

Dr. Barry Weintraub is a top NYC plastic surgeon, board - certified and Ivy League educated at the Weill - Cornell Medical Center. He has over two decades of experience and is a national spokesperson for the American Board of Plastic Surgery. He provides festoon removal (related to eye bags) in NYC.

Patient - Related Information (No direct reviews found but details provided)

• Dr. Weintraub is known for his natural - looking results. He uses various techniques for festoon removal, such as the trans - conjuctival surgical approach and direct removal with microscopic magnification.
• He emphasizes patient safety, preferring patients to be in a comfortable state of twilight sleep during surgery. He also insists on the most sterile conditions in the operating room.
• The best candidates for his festoon excision are well - balanced, in good general and mental health, and have realistic expectations.

Summary

Although there aren't many direct patient reviews, Dr. Weintraub's credentials and his approach to surgery suggest that he is a reliable choice for eyelid bag liposuction, especially for those looking for natural - looking results and high - end surgical care.

4. Dr. Edmund Kwan

Overview

Dr. Edmund Kwan is an Ivy League - trained surgeon with over 20 years of experience. He is known for delivering tasteful plastic surgery with barely visible scars.

Patient Reviews

• Many patients have had multiple procedures with Dr. Kwan and are highly satisfied. A patient who had an eye lift and other facial procedures said, “The procedure was on February 25th, 2020, and it is now August 7th, 2020. I've made a full recovery. There is no swelling and no scars to be seen. I look more refreshed; eyes are more open.”
• Patients also praise his attentive staff and caring bedside manner. “He was attentive and explained everything to me. Even though at first, I felt nervous going to his office, he put me completely at ease as he answered my questions and showed me exactly what he was going to do,” one patient shared.

Summary

Dr. Kwan seems to be a popular choice among patients for eyelid and other plastic surgeries. His skill, combined with a great bedside manner and attentive staff, makes for a positive patient experience.

5. Quatela Center for Plastic Surgery (Dr. Quatela)

Overview

Dr. Quatela at the Quatela Center for Plastic Surgery is world - renowned for his work in the field of plastic surgery, particularly eyelid surgery.

Patient Reviews

• A 63 - year - old woman who had eyelid surgery with Dr. Quatela said, “I found Dr. Quatela to be very personable, professional, and informative. I felt right at ease from the moment I met him. The operation went smoothly, and the discomfort level was very, very tolerable. Now, my eyes look amazing, no scarring, my eyes no longer feel tired, and I am no longer self - conscience about my appearance.”
• The patient also praised the staff, “The office staff completed paperwork for me, took pictures, and went through exactly what the process would be. At each follow - up appointment, all my concerns were addressed, and I was treated extremely well by competent/friendly personnel.”

Summary

Dr. Quatela and his team at the Quatela Center offer a top - notch experience for eyelid surgery patients. The doctor's expertise, along with the excellent staff support, results in highly satisfied patients.

6. Dr. Robert Schwarcz

Overview

Dr. Robert Schwarcz is a cosmetic and reconstructive surgeon in the New York City area, specializing in oculofacial plastic surgery.

Patient Review

• Rae Ann Herman, a patient of Dr. Schwarcz, shared her experience. She had been bothered by under - eye bags for years and was tired of people commenting on her tired appearance. After meeting Dr. Schwarcz, she felt comfortable with his approach. He performed a blepharoplasty, fat graft, and CO2 laser treatment. She said, “Three months in, I see a huge difference. I finally look like myself — like a very well - rested version of myself.”

Summary

Dr. Schwarcz seems to be able to understand his patients' needs and deliver satisfactory results. His personalized approach to achieving a refreshed look is well - received by patients.

7. Dr. Sherrell Aston

Overview

Dr. Sherrell Aston has received awards from professional medical societies and has been named among New York Magazine's best beauty docs. He is frequently featured in magazines such as Vogue and Allure.

Patient Reviews

• Many patients praise Dr. Aston's work. One patient who had a rhinoplasty and upper eye lift said, “The results were so subtle, the recovery was effortless, and the reaction I received was ‘somehow you just look prettier but I am not sure what it is,’ just what I wanted.”
• Another patient who had multiple facial surgeries, including eyelid surgery, said, “Dr. Aston is an amazing surgeon. His work cannot be matched. I look twenty - five years younger.”
• Patients also appreciate his honesty. He advised one patient that she didn't need a face lift when she initially thought she did, showing that he doesn't push unnecessary procedures.

Summary

Dr. Aston is highly regarded for his surgical skills, ability to achieve natural - looking results, and honest approach. His staff is also commended for their support during the entire process.

8. Dr. Jimmy C. Sung

Overview

Dr. Jimmy C. Sung is a board - certified plastic and reconstructive surgeon in New York City. He offers a variety of eyelid plastic surgery procedures and is known for his natural - looking and beautiful results.

Patient Reviews

• Patients have positive things to say about his work on eyelids. One patient who had an Asian double - eyelid surgery said, “It has been 5 weeks post - surgery, and my eyes look so much brighter and give me a younger appearance. Dr. Sung has been so thorough throughout the whole process from consultation, surgery, to post - op.”
• Another patient who had rhinoplasty and eye bag removal stated, “Dr. Sung and his team are so professional and caring. I feel like a new person with my rhinoplasty and eye bag removal done in such a natural and beautiful way.”

Summary

Dr. Sung's clinic offers high - quality eyelid surgeries with a focus on natural results. His patient - centered approach and the professionalism of his team are highly valued by patients.

Comparison of Plastic Hospitals

Conclusion

In 2025, New York City has a wide range of plastic hospitals and surgeons offering eyelid bag liposuction. Each doctor has their own strengths, whether it's surgical skill, patient - centered care, or a particular technique. Based on the reviews, Dr. Amiya Prasad, Dr. Edmund Kwan, Dr. Quatela, Dr. Sherrell Aston, and Dr. Jimmy C. Sung seem to have consistently positive feedback from patients, indicating a high level of satisfaction with their services. On the other hand, while Dr. Basil Pakeman has some satisfied patients, his mixed reviews suggest a bit more risk. Dr. Barry Weintraub, with his strong credentials, is a potential option despite the lack of extensive direct patient reviews.

If you're considering eyelid bag liposuction in New York City, it's essential to do your own research, consult multiple surgeons, and look at before - and - after photos. Don't hesitate to ask questions about the procedure, recovery, and potential risks. We encourage you to share this article with friends and family who might be interested in eyelid bag liposuction, and feel free to explore other related topics on our site to learn more about plastic surgery options in New York City.