Strength Ranking of Doctors for External Eyelid Blepharoplasty to Remove Eye Bags in New York City in 2025

Introduction

External eyelid blepharoplasty, also known as eyelid surgery, is a highly sought - after cosmetic procedure in New York City. It helps to rejuvenate the appearance of the eyes by removing excess skin, fat, and muscle from the eyelids, thereby reducing eye bags and giving a more youthful and refreshed look. With numerous doctors offering this service in the city, it can be a daunting task for patients to choose the right one. This article aims to provide a comprehensive strength ranking of doctors for external eyelid blepharoplasty in New York City based on various factors, including patient ratings, experience, and surgical techniques.

Strength Ranking of Doctors for External Eyelid Blepharoplasty to Remove Eye Bags in New York City in 2025!

What is External Eyelid Blepharoplasty?

External eyelid blepharoplasty is a specialized surgical procedure that focuses on improving the appearance of the eyelids. The term “blepharoplasty” comes from the Greek word “blepharos,” which means “eye, eyelid.” The surgery can be divided into upper and lower blepharoplasty, each targeting different areas of concern.

Upper Blepharoplasty: This procedure involves removing excess skin, fat, and muscle from the upper eyelids. It is often used to correct drooping eyelids and improve vision that may be obstructed by sagging skin. Incisions are made within the natural creases of the upper eyelid to minimize visible scarring. After the removal of the unwanted tissue, the eyelid is tightened and lifted, creating a more youthful and alert appearance. According to franckmd.com, upper blepharoplasty is typically done under local anesthesia with sedation, although some patients may opt for general anesthesia depending on their comfort levels and individual needs.
Lower Blepharoplasty: Lower blepharoplasty targets under - eye bags, excess skin, and puffiness in the lower eyelid area. Incisions can be made either just below the lash line or inside the lower lid (transconjunctival approach). By removing or repositioning excess fat and skin, the lower eyelid is smoothed and tightened, resulting in a refreshed and rejuvenated look. The transconjunctival approach, which is popular for younger patients with good skin elasticity, avoids external scars as the incision is made inside the eyelid. On the other hand, the sub - ciliary incision (below the lash line) may be used when skin tightening is required.

Factors Affecting the Strength of Doctors in Blepharoplasty

Patient Ratings: Patient ratings are a valuable indicator of a doctor's performance. Platforms like Healthgrades provide insights into the experiences of previous patients. A high - rated doctor is more likely to have satisfied patients, as these ratings are based on factors such as the doctor's bedside manner, surgical results, and post - operative care. For example, doctors with a rating of 4.5 or above out of 5 stars on Healthgrades are generally considered to be providing high - quality services.
Experience: Years of experience in performing blepharoplasty procedures matter significantly. Experienced doctors are more likely to have encountered a wide range of cases and developed the skills to handle complex situations. They are also more proficient in surgical techniques, which can lead to better results and fewer complications. Doctors who have been performing blepharoplasty for over 10 or 20 years often have a wealth of knowledge and expertise in the field.
Board Certification: Board - certified plastic surgeons have met certain standards of education, training, and experience. For blepharoplasty, a board - certified plastic surgeon or a board - certified facial plastic surgeon is more likely to have the necessary skills and knowledge to perform the procedure safely and effectively. For instance, a doctor certified by the American Board of Plastic Surgery or the American Academy of Facial Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery has demonstrated a high level of competence in the field.
Surgical Techniques: The use of advanced and appropriate surgical techniques can greatly influence the outcome of a blepharoplasty procedure. Surgeons who are updated with the latest techniques and technologies are more likely to achieve natural - looking results with minimal scarring and downtime. For example, some surgeons may specialize in transconjunctival blepharoplasty for younger patients or use laser resurfacing in conjunction with blepharoplasty to enhance the overall appearance of the eyelids.
Patient Testimonials: Real - life stories from patients can give a good idea of a doctor's ability to meet patient expectations. Positive testimonials often mention the doctor's attention to detail, communication skills, and the quality of the surgical results. These testimonials can be found on the doctor's website, online review platforms, or social media.

Strength Ranking of Doctors in New York City

Based on information from Healthgrades and other sources, here is a list of some of the top doctors for external eyelid blepharoplasty in New York City:

Doctor's Name	Rating (out of 5)	Location	Special Features
Dr. Lisa Gfrerer, MD	5.00	515 6th Street, Brooklyn, NY 11215	On staff at New York - Presbyterian / Weill Cornell Medical Center
Dr. Lora Dagi Glass, MD	5.00	880 Third Avenue, New York, NY 10022	-
Dr. Elena Geller, MD	5.00	309 W 23rd St, New York, NY 10011	-
Dr. Brendan Finnerty, MD	5.00	520 East 70th Street Starr Pavilion, 8th floor, New York, NY 10021	On staff at New York - Presbyterian Lower Manhattan Hospital
Dr. Harsha Reddy, MD	5.00	77 Worth St, New York, NY 10013	-
Dr. Bryan Winn, MD	4.60	880 3rd Ave Fl 2, New York, NY 10022	-
Dr. William Schiff, MD	4.60	210 E 64th St Fl 7, New York, NY 10065	On staff at Lenox Hill Hospital
Dr. Paul Langer, MD	4.50	90 Bergen St, Newark, NJ 07103	-
Dr. Michael Kazim, MD	4.50	630 W 168th St, New York, NY 10032	-
Dr. Neil Nichols, MD	4.40	114 E 27th St, New York, NY 10016	-
Dr. Christopher Starr, MD	4.40	1305 York Avenue 12th floor, New York, NY 10021	-
Dr. Emil Chynn, MD	4.40	102 E 25th St, New York, NY 10010	-
Dr. David Freilich, MD	4.30	14 E 96th St Apt C, New York, NY 10128	-
Dr. I Rodgers, MD	4.30	229 E 79th St, New York, NY 10075	-
Dr. Rasa Zarnegar, MD	4.80	525 E. 68th Street, New York, NY 10065	On staff at New York - Presbyterian Lower Manhattan Hospital

Detailed Profiles of Top - Ranked Doctors

Dr. Lisa Gfrerer, MD

Dr. Lisa Gfrerer has a perfect 5 - star rating on Healthgrades. She is affiliated with New York - Presbyterian / Weill Cornell Medical Center, which is a prestigious institution. This affiliation suggests that she has access to advanced medical resources and a high - level of medical support. Patients can expect her to be well - versed in the latest surgical techniques and have a thorough understanding of patient safety and care.

Dr. Bryan Winn, MD

With a rating of 4.6 out of 5 stars, Dr. Bryan Winn is another highly regarded doctor in New York City. His practice is located at 880 3rd Ave Fl 2, New York, NY 10022. While the exact number of years of experience is not specified in the available sources, his high rating indicates that he has a good track record of providing satisfactory results to his patients. He may be particularly skilled in performing blepharoplasty with a focus on achieving natural - looking outcomes.

Dr. Rasa Zarnegar, MD

Dr. Rasa Zarnegar, with a 4.8 - star rating, is on staff at New York - Presbyterian Lower Manhattan Hospital. This suggests that she has a high level of professional standing and access to state - of - the - art facilities. Her experience and skills likely enable her to handle a variety of blepharoplasty cases, including those that may be more complex due to factors such as the patient's age, skin condition, or underlying medical issues.

The Consultation Process

Before undergoing blepharoplasty, patients should schedule a consultation with their chosen doctor. The consultation is a crucial step as it allows the doctor to assess the patient's suitability for the procedure and for the patient to learn more about the surgery.

Assessment of Eyelids: The doctor will carefully examine the patient's eyelids to evaluate the amount of excess skin, fat, and muscle. They will also consider the elasticity of the skin and the overall shape of the eyes. For example, if a patient has significant sagging of the upper eyelids, the doctor may recommend a more extensive upper blepharoplasty. This assessment helps in determining the most appropriate surgical approach for each individual patient.
Medical Review: The doctor will review the patient's medical history, including any pre - existing eye conditions, medications, or previous surgeries. This is important to identify any potential risks or complications associated with the surgery. For instance, patients with glaucoma or dry eye syndrome may require special precautions during and after the procedure. In some cases, the doctor may also request a clearance from an ophthalmologist to ensure the patient's eye health is stable for surgery.
Procedure Explanation: The doctor will explain the details of the blepharoplasty procedure, including the type of anesthesia that will be used, the expected duration of the surgery, and the likely recovery process. They will also discuss the different techniques available and which one is most suitable for the patient. Patients should have a clear understanding of what to expect before, during, and after the surgery.
Questions and Concerns: The consultation is also an opportunity for patients to ask any questions or express any concerns they may have. This could include questions about the surgical risks, the expected results, or the cost of the procedure. Open communication between the patient and the doctor is essential to ensure that the patient feels comfortable and well - informed about the surgery.

Recovery Process

The recovery process after blepharoplasty is an important aspect of the overall experience. Different patients may have different recovery times and experiences, but there are some general guidelines:

First Week: Patients can expect to experience mild swelling, bruising, and irritation in the first week after surgery. Cold compresses and keeping the head elevated can help reduce swelling. Most patients are advised to rest and avoid strenuous activities during this time. Some patients may also experience temporary changes in vision, such as blurred or double vision, which usually resolves on its own.
Stitch Removal: Sutures are typically removed within 5 - 7 days after surgery. The doctor will carefully remove the stitches to minimize any discomfort. After stitch removal, the patient may notice that the swelling and bruising start to improve more rapidly.
Returning to Normal Activities: Many patients can resume light activities within a week or two after surgery. However, strenuous exercise and activities that may cause sweating or increased blood pressure should be avoided for a few weeks. Full recovery may take a few months, but most patients start to see the final results of the surgery as the swelling diminishes.

Combining Blepharoplasty with Other Procedures

Some patients may choose to combine blepharoplasty with other facial rejuvenation procedures to achieve more comprehensive results:

Brow Lift: A brow lift can be combined with blepharoplasty to further enhance the eye area. Lifting a droopy brow can create a more youthful and refreshed look, especially when combined with upper blepharoplasty. The brow lift helps to correct the position of the eyebrows, which can have a significant impact on the overall appearance of the eyes.
Facelift: For patients with sagging skin in the mid - to - lower face, a facelift can be combined with blepharoplasty. This combination addresses multiple signs of aging, such as jowls and loose skin, in addition to the concerns around the eyes. It provides a more holistic approach to facial rejuvenation.
Skin Resurfacing: Laser or chemical peels can be used in conjunction with blepharoplasty to improve the texture of the skin around the eyes. Skin resurfacing helps to reduce fine lines and wrinkles, giving the skin a smoother and more youthful appearance. This combination can enhance the overall results of the blepharoplasty procedure.

Risks and Complications

Like any surgical procedure, blepharoplasty carries certain risks and potential complications:

Infection or Bleeding: Although uncommon, there is a risk of infection or bleeding after the surgery. Proper wound care and following the doctor's post - operative instructions can help minimize this risk. Patients should keep the surgical area clean and dry and report any signs of infection, such as redness, swelling, or discharge, to their doctor immediately.
Dryness or Irritation: Some patients may experience dryness or irritation in the eyes after surgery. This can usually be alleviated with prescribed eye drops. The doctor may recommend using artificial tears regularly to keep the eyes moist and comfortable during the recovery period.
Temporary Changes in Vision: Blurred or double vision can occur temporarily after blepharoplasty. This usually resolves on its own as the eyes heal. However, if the vision changes persist or worsen, the patient should contact their doctor for further evaluation.
Scarring: While the incisions are usually placed in inconspicuous areas to minimize scarring,