Introduction

In the vibrant city of New York, where beauty standards are ever - evolving, external eyelid blepharoplasty has gained significant popularity. This surgical procedure offers a solution to those looking to rejuvenate their eye area, addressing issues such as sagging eyelids, under - eye bags, and a tired appearance. With numerous plastic surgeons offering this service, it can be challenging to choose the right one. In this article, we'll explore the top 5 plastic surgeons in New York City for external eyelid blepharoplasty, providing detailed insights into their practices, patient testimonials, and the unique aspects of their services.

Understanding External Eyelid Blepharoplasty

What is External Eyelid Blepharoplasty?

External eyelid blepharoplasty is a surgical procedure designed to enhance the appearance of the eyes by removing excess skin, fat, and muscle from the upper and lower eyelids. The word “blepharoplasty” comes from the Greek “blepharos,” meaning “eye, eyelid.” This procedure can not only improve the aesthetic appearance of the eyes but also enhance peripheral vision if sagging eyelids are obstructing the sight. It is one of the most commonly performed facial plastic procedures, suitable for both men and women of various ages.

Benefits of External Eyelid Blepharoplasty

• Enhanced Appearance: It provides a brighter, more alert look, making individuals appear years younger.
• Improved Vision: Removing sagging skin can expand the field of vision, especially if droopiness was causing obstruction.
• Reduction of Under - Eye Bags: The procedure can eliminate or significantly reduce the appearance of under - eye bags, giving the eyes a fresher and rejuvenated look.
• Long - Lasting Results: Although the natural aging process continues, the outcomes of blepharoplasty often last for many years, making it a worthwhile investment.

The Top 5 Plastic Surgeons for External Eyelid Blepharoplasty in New York City in 2025

1. Dr. Jennifer Levine

Profile

Dr. Jennifer Levine is well - known as one of the best surgeons on the east coast. She has a reputation for delivering natural - looking results with minimal recovery time. She is a double - board certified facial plastic surgeon, and her vast experience with eyelid lifts and other facial procedures gives her the knowledge to achieve successful outcomes. She has performed countless blepharoplasty procedures in her New York City office.

Patient Experience

Patients appreciate her personalized approach. For example, Amanda, a recent patient, came to Dr. Levine before her 30th birthday. They collaborated on a custom treatment plan that included an upper eyelid lift, ultherapy skin treatments, and a neuromodulator regimen. Amanda was able to achieve her goal of looking her best and prolonging her youthful glow.

Techniques and Procedures

Dr. Levine focuses on achieving results that match the patient's original appearance and boost confidence. She can perform upper, lower, or combined blepharoplasty, removing excess skin and fat to correct drooping eyelids and puffiness. Her surgeries are performed in her private surgical suite in New York City, under general or local anesthesia for patient comfort.

2. Dr. Lara Devgan, MD, MPH, FACS

Profile

Dr. Lara Devgan offers beautiful, natural results for blepharoplasty. Her practice in New York City caters to both local and international patients. She performs blepharoplasties under sedation administered by a board - certified anesthesiologist and uses protective corneal shields to ensure patient safety.

Patient Experience

She has received numerous positive testimonials from patients. For instance, a 63 - year - old man, Andrew Metcalfe, had a facelift/neck lift and upper & lower eyelid blepharoplasty with Dr. Devgan. He reported feeling transformed and looking at least ten years younger, and he highly recommended her due to her excellent surgical skills and empathetic approach.

Techniques and Procedures

Dr. Devgan's blepharoplasty procedures are short outpatient surgeries. All scars are either hidden inside the pink part of the eyelids or camouflaged along a skin crease. After the procedure, patients can usually go home the same day and resume normal activities within 1 - 2 days, although swelling and bruising may take at least one week to subside.

3. Dr. David Cangello

Profile

Dr. David Cangello is one of the top board - certified plastic surgeons in New York City. He approaches plastic surgery with an artistic eye and combines this with surgical expertise. His practice at Cangello Plastic Surgery is known for providing top - notch results and personalized care.

Patient Experience

He believes in building a strong doctor - patient relationship. During the consultation, he takes the time to understand the patient's concerns and goals. For example, he conducts a physical examination of the eyelids and periocular tissues, reviews the medical history, and then creates a tailored treatment plan that may include additional procedures like a facelift or fat transfer.

Techniques and Procedures

For upper eyelid blepharoplasty, the incision follows the natural crease in the eyelid, making the scar virtually undetectable. For lower eyelid surgery, the incision is made inside the eyelid or just below the lower lash line. The procedure usually takes about forty - five to ninety minutes, depending on whether one or both sets of eyelids are being operated on.

4. Dr. Adam R. Kolker, MD

Profile

Dr. Adam R. Kolker is a plastic surgeon in New York City who is skilled in all nuances and techniques of eye area rejuvenation. He brings vast experience, technical finesse, and artistry to achieve beautiful results in blepharoplasty.

Patient Experience

Patients appreciate his attention to detail and warm bedside manner. Kristen Foodim had a full facial rejuvenation surgery plan with Dr. Kolker, including a blepharoplasty, and she was very satisfied with the results, stating that she finally looked as good as she felt.

Techniques and Procedures

He offers a variety of eyelid rejuvenation techniques, such as non - surgical lower eyelid rejuvenation using injectable facial fillers, laser resurfacing, skin - pinch blepharoplasty, transconjunctival blepharoplasty, fat grafts for tear trough and volume loss, and lower eyelid fat repositioning. He selects the most appropriate technique based on the patient's specific needs.

5. Dr. John E. Sherman

Profile

Dr. John E. Sherman is a board - certified plastic surgeon with over 40 years of experience in the field. He specializes in facial rejuvenation and is well - known for his expertise in blepharoplasty in New York City.

Patient Experience

A patient who had upper and lower eyelid surgery with Dr. Sherman reported a very caring and professional experience, and was extremely happy with the virtually painless procedure and the results. The patient recommended him without reservation.

Techniques and Procedures

Dr. Sherman offers several options for blepharoplasty. For younger patients, he may perform transconjunctival blepharoplasty, which involves making an incision inside the eyelid to remove fat without a visible scar. For older patients, he may perform lower eyelid resuspension or canthopexy to reposition or tighten the lower eyelid. He also offers laser resurfacing of the eyelids to provide a younger, fresher look.

Comparing the Top 5 Surgeons

Factors to Consider When Choosing a Plastic Surgeon for External Eyelid Blepharoplasty

Credentials and Experience

It is crucial to choose a board - certified plastic surgeon with extensive experience in performing external eyelid blepharoplasty. Surgeons like Dr. Jennifer Levine, Dr. Lara Devgan, Dr. David Cangello, Dr. Adam R. Kolker, and Dr. John E. Sherman have all demonstrated their expertise through their credentials and a long history of successful procedures.

Patient Testimonials

Reading patient testimonials can give you an idea of the surgeon's bedside manner, the quality of their work, and the patient experience. Positive testimonials from real patients, as seen with the top 5 surgeons mentioned above, are a good sign of a surgeon's reliability and skill.

Techniques and Approach

Different surgeons may use different techniques for external eyelid blepharoplasty. Some may focus on minimizing scarring, while others may offer a combination of surgical and non - surgical options. It's important to discuss the available techniques with the surgeon and choose one that aligns with your goals and preferences.

Cost and Financing

The cost of external eyelid blepharoplasty can vary depending on several factors, such as the complexity of the procedure, the surgeon's fees, and the location. Some surgeons, like Dr. John E. Sherman, offer financing options to make the procedure more affordable. It's essential to have a clear understanding of the costs involved and to discuss financing options with the surgeon during the consultation.

Preparing for External Eyelid Blepharoplasty

Consultation

The consultation is a crucial step in the process. During the consultation, the surgeon will evaluate your eyelids, review your medical history, and discuss your goals and expectations. They will also explain the procedure, including the anesthesia options, likely recovery timelines, and any potential risks or complications. For example, Dr. David Cangello takes the time to understand the patient's concerns and creates a personalized treatment plan during the consultation.

Pre - operative Instructions

Most surgeons will provide pre - operative instructions to ensure a successful procedure. These may include ceasing the intake of blood thinners and certain supplements, stopping smoking several weeks before and after the surgery, arranging transportation home after the procedure, and setting aside adequate recovery time from work and social commitments. Dr. John E. Sherman provides detailed pre - operative instructions to his patients, such as discontinuing blood thinners and nicotine use.

Recovery from External Eyelid Blepharoplasty

Immediate Post - operative Period

After the surgery, patients can usually go home the same day. They may experience mild swelling, bruising, or irritation. Cold compresses and head elevation are often recommended to reduce swelling. Pain medication may be prescribed to alleviate any discomfort. For example, after Dr. Lara Devgan's blepharoplasty procedures, patients are given an ice pack over their eyes for several minutes after waking up.

Stitch Removal

Sutures are usually removed within 5 - 7 days. This may vary depending on the surgeon and the type of procedure. For instance, Dr. Jennifer Levine removes the fine sutures used in upper eyelid blepharoplasty four days later.

Returning to Normal Activities

Many people can resume light activities within a week or two, but strenuous exercise should be avoided for a few weeks. Makeup can usually be worn within five days, but it's best to avoid it for as long as possible to ensure proper healing. Full healing can take a few months, but changes are noticeable much sooner.

Risks and Complications of External Eyelid Blepharoplasty

Like any surgical procedure, external eyelid blepharoplasty carries certain risks and potential complications. However, these occurrences are usually rare, especially when the procedure is performed by a skilled and experienced plastic surgeon. Some of the possible risks include:

• Infection or Bleeding: Proper wound care and following post - operative instructions can help minimize this risk.
• Dryness or Irritation: Eyes may feel dry or irritated following surgery, and prescribed eye drops can usually alleviate this symptom.
• Temporary Changes in Vision: Blurred or double vision can occur but typically resolves on its own.
• Scarring: Although scars are usually discreet and well - concealed, some individuals may experience more visible scarring.

Conclusion

External eyelid blepharoplasty is a popular and effective procedure for enhancing the appearance of the eyes and achieving a more youthful look. In New York City, there are several highly skilled plastic surgeons, such as Dr. Jennifer Levine, Dr. Lara Devgan, Dr. David Cangello, Dr. Adam R. Kolker, and Dr. John E. Sherman, who offer excellent services in this area. When considering this procedure, it's important to do thorough research, consider the factors mentioned above, and choose a surgeon who meets your needs and expectations. Remember to have realistic expectations, follow the pre - and post - operative instructions carefully, and enjoy the benefits of a refreshed and rejuvenated eye area.

If you're interested in learning more about external eyelid blepharoplasty or scheduling a consultation with one of the top 5 surgeons in New York City, don't hesitate to reach out. Contact the surgeon's office directly to get started on your journey to a more beautiful you!