Introduction
Small - incision double - eyelid surgery has become a popular cosmetic procedure, and New York City, as a global metropolis, offers a wide range of options for patients. In this article, we will explore the rankings of public departments related to this surgery, as well as provide comprehensive information about the surgery itself, including surgeons, clinics, and hospitals, along with related factors such as recovery, costs, and potential risks.
Understanding Small - Incision Double - Eyelid Surgery
Small - incision double - eyelid surgery, also a type of blepharoplasty, is favored for its relatively less invasive nature compared to full - incisional methods. According to a systematic review on small - incisional techniques for double - eyelid blepharoplasty, these techniques have increasingly gained popularity. The small - incisional techniques offer a simple, safe, and reproducible approach to creating double - eyelids. It reduces post - op recovery time and allows a tenacious fixation. The fold - loss rate and other complication rate are acceptable when compared with the non - incisional and full - incisional techniques.
There are different variations of small - incision techniques, including single - incisional, two - incisional, three - incisional, and four - incisional methods. Through the small incisions, the pretarsal soft tissue can be removed as appropriate, and the pretarsal fixation can be firm and exact.
Ranking of Surgeons
Newsweek Rankings 2023
In the 2023 Newsweek rankings of America's Best Plastic Surgeons for eyelid surgery, several surgeons from New York City were recognized. Sherrell J. Aston, MD, Glenn W. Jelks, MD, Alan Matarasso, MD, FACS, Daniel C. Baker, MD, David Hidalgo, MD, FACS, John E. Sherman, MD, FACS, and Charles H. Thorne, MD, all from New York, made it onto the list. The ranking was based on a comprehensive scoring model that included in - state and out - of - state recommendations, a quality assessment, and relevant certification.
The scoring model for the Newsweek rankings was as follows:
- In - state recommendations (45% of the overall score): Participants were asked to name the leading plastic surgeons for each procedure in their own state. The order of recommendations was relevant to the ranking, and self - recommendations were not allowed.
- Out - of - state recommendations (35% of the overall score): Participants named leading plastic surgeons for each procedure outside their own state among the 20 states included in the survey.
- Quality score (15% of the total score): For in - state recommendations, participants assessed the quality of care, such as consultation with the doctor, complications, follow - up, and outcome, on a scale from 1 (poor) to 10 (excellent).
- Certification score (5% of the total score): Plastic surgeons with American Board of Plastic Surgery (ABPS) accreditation received 5% towards their total score.
Healthgrades Rankings
Healthgrades also provides rankings of eyelid surgery doctors in New York. Doctors like Dr. Rasa Zarnegar, MD (rated 4.80 out of 5 stars), Dr. Brendan Finnerty, MD (rated 5.00 out of 5 stars), and Dr. Harsha Reddy, MD (rated 5.00 out of 5 stars) were highly rated. These rankings are based on past patient ratings, which can give patients an idea of the doctor's experience and the quality of care they provide.
| Surgeon | Rating | Location |
|---|---|---|
| Dr. Rasa Zarnegar, MD | 4.80 | 525 e. 68th street, New York, NY 10065 |
| Dr. Brendan Finnerty, MD | 5.00 | 520 east 70th street starr pavilion, 8th floor, New York, NY 10021 |
| Dr. Harsha Reddy, MD | 5.00 | 77 worth st, New York, NY 10013 |
Ranking of Clinics
MediJump lists several clinics in New York City for eyelid surgery. Some of the highly rated clinics include:
- Center Aesthetic & Dermatology: Rated 5.0. The clinic is known for its friendly staff and high - quality work. Patients appreciate the natural - looking results achieved by Nurse Lynn.
- Sophie Bartsich, MD FACS: Also rated 5.0. Dr. Bartsich is a top - notch cosmetic surgeon in Manhattan, with excellent surgical skills and great bedside manners.
- A. Joshua Zimm MD. Facial Plastic & Reconstructive Surgery: Rated 4.9. After a referral from a physician colleague, patients have been highly satisfied with Dr. Zimm's work. He takes the time to explain procedures and addresses patients' goals effectively.
Most clinics do not publicly disclose the prices for eyelid surgery, and the pricing is usually available on request. The cost of eyelid surgery in New York City can be influenced by factors such as the experience and skill of the surgeon, the complexity of the operation, and the operational facilities.
Ranking of Hospitals
U.S. News provides rankings of hospitals for ophthalmology in New York City. New York - Presbyterian Hospital - Columbia and Cornell is high - performing in ophthalmology, with a score of 4.3%. The New York Eye and Ear Infirmary of Mount Sinai is ranked #12 in ophthalmology hospitals, with a score of 5.3%. Manhattan Eye, Ear & Throat Hospital and NYU Langone Hospitals also have their respective scores and national rankings in adult and pediatric specialties.
| Hospital | Ophthalmology Score | National Rankings |
|---|---|---|
| New York - Presbyterian Hospital - Columbia and Cornell | 4.3% | Nationally ranked in 14 adult specialties and 10 pediatric specialties |
| New York Eye and Ear Infirmary of Mount Sinai | 5.3% | Nationally ranked in 1 adult specialty |
| Manhattan Eye, Ear & Throat Hospital | 2.8% | Nationally ranked in 9 adult specialties |
| NYU Langone Hospitals | 2.4% | Nationally ranked in 14 adult specialties and 3 pediatric specialties |
The Surgery Process
Pre - surgery
Before small - incision double - eyelid surgery, patients usually have a consultation with the surgeon. The surgeon will assess the patient's facial features, eyelid condition, and expectations. For example, Dr. Adam Kolker conducts a comprehensive discussion and examination in his office on Park Avenue in New York. He may also recommend a non - surgical eyelid rejuvenation approach in some cases. Patients are usually given a list of "dos and don'ts," including stopping smoking and certain medications in advance, and having routine laboratory testing.
During surgery
During the operation, local anesthesia is commonly used, and sometimes a mild sedative is added to ease the patient's nervousness. The surgeon makes small incisions following the natural folds of the eyelid, removes excess skin, fat, and muscle tissue, and then stitches the incisions shut. The length of the surgery can range from approximately 45 minutes to two hours, depending on the specific techniques and the patient's individual situation.
Post - surgery
After the surgery, patients recover in a recovery room under the care of a registered nurse. Cold compresses are used to minimize bruising and swelling. The primary swelling and bruising usually resolve in about one week, and most patients can return to work or social activities around this time. Suture removal is generally at 5 to 7 days after the surgery, and eye drops may be recommended for several weeks. Surgeons like Dr. Kolker and his staff are available to assist patients with any questions or recovery - related matters.
Recovery and Aftercare
Recovery time
The recovery time for small - incision double - eyelid surgery can vary from person to person. Generally, patients can expect to have some swelling and bruising around the eyes for up to two weeks. After about five days, most people can resume their normal routine, but contact lens wearers need to wait at least two weeks before using their lenses again.
Aftercare instructions
Surgeons provide specific aftercare instructions. Patients are advised to be gentle with their eyelids, clean them carefully, and use prescribed eye drops or creams. They should also avoid scratching their eyes and stay away from smoky environments. Wearing sunglasses with a good, dark tint when going outside is recommended to protect the eyes and the sensitive skin around them from the sun and wind.
Costs and Insurance
The cost of small - incision double - eyelid surgery in New York City is influenced by multiple factors. Generally, the price per eye can range from $2,000 to $5,000 for the surgeon's fee alone, excluding other costs such as anesthesia and operating room services. Classic health insurance usually does not cover the costs of cosmetic operations like this surgery. However, if the surgery is for health - related or functional reasons, such as correcting vision problems caused by sagging eyelids, insurance may cover most of the cost. It is advisable for patients to verify with their insurance broker and the chosen healthcare center.
Potential Risks and Complications
Like any surgical procedure, small - incision double - eyelid surgery has potential risks and complications. These may include infection, hemorrhage, scarring, challenges in shutting the eyes, dry ocular condition, and a mismatch in the size between the two eyelids. In rare instances, patients may also experience temporary or lasting alterations in their eyesight. It is crucial for patients to discuss these risks with their medical practitioner before the surgery and understand the doctor's approach to managing them.
Alternatives to Surgery
For those who are hesitant about surgery, there are alternative methods to achieve similar results. Laser interventions, Botox, HIFU, and Ulthera are some of the non - surgical options. However, these alternatives may not be suitable for everyone, and patients should consult with a medical expert to determine the best course of action for their specific needs.
Conclusion
When considering small - incision double - eyelid surgery in New York City, patients have a wide range of options in terms of surgeons, clinics, and hospitals. Rankings from various sources can serve as a useful guide, but it is also important to consider other factors such as the surgeon's experience, the clinic's or hospital's facilities, and patient reviews. Understanding the surgery process, recovery, costs, and potential risks is essential for making an informed decision.
We encourage you to share this article with others who may be interested in small - incision double - eyelid surgery. If you have further questions or would like to learn more about related topics, feel free to explore other resources or consult with a qualified medical professional.
